Blog 31: The Implications of a 4.5% Interest Rate Hike: A Comprehensive Analysis

This article was written by GPT4, it is trained on data only up to September 2021 and is unaware that the FED rate hikes of 2022 happened and of the current Financial Crisis, Let's see what it can tell us about our current predicament when asked the right questions by a Risk Manager.

The Federal Reserve (FED) plays a crucial role in the stability and growth of the US economy through its monetary policy decisions. In this blog post, we will explore a hypothetical scenario where the FED increases interest rates by 4.5% within a year. We will discuss the potential consequences of this drastic change, focusing on long-term fixed interest rate debt, the risks involved, and the impact on banks, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the broader economy.

  1. Long-term fixed interest rate debt and its average time to maturity

As of September 2021, the US market has approximately $49 trillion in outstanding fixed-rate debt, of which long-term debt (maturing in ten years or more) amounts to around $17.5 trillion. The average time to maturity for this long-term debt is approximately 24 years. This debt includes various financial instruments such as Treasury bonds, corporate bonds, and mortgage-backed securities (MBS).

  1. Interest rate risk for holders of long-term low-interest rate mortgages

While long-term low-interest rate mortgages are beneficial for homeowners, the holders of these debts are exposed to interest rate risk. This risk arises when interest rates increase, causing the value of fixed-rate debt instruments to decrease. As the interest rates rise, newly issued debt instruments with higher yields become more attractive to investors, leading to a decline in demand and market value of existing lower-yielding securities.

In our scenario of a 4.5% interest rate hike, the value of existing long-term fixed-rate debt would decline significantly. This could lead to substantial losses for investors and institutions holding these securities, potentially causing financial instability and affecting the broader economy.

  1. The distribution of risky mortgage debt and potential strains in the financial market

Mortgage-backed securities, which bundle individual mortgages into tradeable securities, are primarily held by institutional investors such as pension funds, insurance companies, and mutual funds. Banks and government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac also hold a significant portion of this debt.

In the case of a 4.5% interest rate hike, the value of these securities would decline, leading to losses for their holders. This could result in margin calls, forced selling, and liquidity constraints, potentially causing strain and instability in the financial markets.

  1. The impact on banks and the possibility of a credit and liquidity crisis

An interest rate hike of 4.57% would have a considerable impact on banks. As the value of their long-term fixed-rate debt holdings declines, their balance sheets would weaken, reducing their lending capacity. This could lead to a credit crunch, making it difficult for businesses and households to access credit and causing a slowdown in economic growth.

Furthermore, banks may face liquidity issues as they scramble to meet margin calls and cover their losses. This could force them to sell assets at fire-sale prices, further exacerbating the decline in asset values and potentially triggering a liquidity crisis.

  1. The effect on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, as key players in the US mortgage market, would also be heavily affected by a 4.5% interest rate hike. Their balance sheets would suffer from the decline in the value of mortgage-backed securities, and their ability to support the housing market by purchasing and securitizing mortgages would be reduced.

In a worst-case scenario, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac could face insolvency, requiring government intervention to stabilize the housing market and prevent a more severe crisis.

  1. Likely actions by central banks and governments, and the impact on inflation and debt levels

If a crisis emerges due to a sudden 4.5% interest rate hike, central 

banks and governments would likely take several actions to mitigate the negative consequences and stabilize the financial markets. These actions might include:

a) Lowering interest rates: The FED could reverse its decision and lower interest rates to reduce the pressure on banks, homeowners, and other debt holders. This would help restore confidence in the markets and alleviate some of the stress on financial institutions.

b) Quantitative easing (QE): Central banks could initiate new rounds of QE, buying assets such as government bonds and mortgage-backed securities to inject liquidity into the financial system. This would help stabilize asset prices and support the availability of credit in the economy.

c) Fiscal stimulus: Governments could implement fiscal stimulus measures, such as tax cuts or increased public spending, to boost economic activity and counteract the negative impact of the crisis.

d) Financial support for affected institutions: Governments and central banks could provide financial assistance to struggling banks, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac to prevent insolvency and protect the stability of the financial system.

These actions, however, would have implications for inflation and debt levels. Lower interest rates and QE could lead to increased inflationary pressures, as they would boost the money supply and potentially weaken the currency. Fiscal stimulus measures would also increase public debt, which could exacerbate long-term fiscal sustainability concerns.

In conclusion, a rapid 4.5% interest rate hike by the FED would have significant consequences for the US economy, particularly for long-term fixed interest rate debt holders, banks, and government-sponsored enterprises like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. While central banks and governments have tools to mitigate the crisis, these actions may also have unintended consequences for inflation and debt levels.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.